Shop for Cincinnatti Bengals gear at

No Franchise Player?

Will the Bengals let Benson walk?

Even without an existing CBA, teams have been permitted to designate franchise players, and under the current rules, they can also designate up to 2 transition players.  Many teams have tagged franchise players including all 3 divisional rivals.  Cleveland tagged kicker Phil Dawson, Pittsburgh tagged LB Lamar Woodley, and Baltimore tagged DT Haloti Ngata.

We debated in this space who the Bengals might tag, with CB Johnathan Joseph and RB Cedric Benson looking like the only two players worthy of the tag. We argued for Benson.  Word is coming out that for the second year in a row the Bengals will not tag anyone, leaving both Joseph and Benson to test the waters of free agency (whenever that may begin).

If true, it’s an interesting gamble by the team.  Letting Joseph walk seems reasonable, considering the hefty pricetag for franchising cornerbacks (over 14 million/year), and the fact that their most steady CB, Leon Hall, is heading into the last year of his contract. 

Benson, however, is a bit of a surprise.  Why would the team not work to secure their bell-cow back? Especially when it has been widely reported by Marvin Lewis wants to return to a smash-mouth, run-based offense.  Without Benson, the team will most certainly need to draft at least one runningback, and make a push for other veteran help.

I suppose the argument here is that runningbacks are relatively cheap and easy to replace, or so current wisdom would have us believe.  I would argue against that line of thinking.  After all, the Bengals have struggled in the past with poor runningbacks as recently has 2008, when Benson was called off the couch due to the failures of Chris Perry and Kenny Irons.

Perhaps the Bengals are balking at the pricetag for Benson as a franchise player (approximately 9 million) and think they can bring him back for less, or get a comparable alternative.  There has been speculation in the past that the team would pursue Raiders RB Michael Bush of Louisville.   Bush has good size at 6-1 and 245, but he never topped 1,000 yards and only started 10 games in three years in Oakland. Plus he got a DUI arrest early this month in Indiana.

Other backs to be had in a fairly deep free agent pool include DeAngelo Williams of Carolina, Ahmad Bradshaw of the Giants, BenJarvis Green-Ellis of New England, Mike Tolbert of San Diego, Ronnie Brown of Miami, Cadillac Williams of Tampa Bay, and Joseph Addai of Indianapolis.

Perhaps they feel the depth of this year’s class will drive down the prices.  They may be right, but it’s a gamble for sure, and aruguably one they don’t have the depth, or political rope to make at this point.

Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to Bengals Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

2 Responses to “No Franchise Player?”

  1. bengals69 says:

    Ghee was drafted for just the reason of $14million tag cost.
    Adam Jones was signed as insurance for JJoe. The Bengals I’m sure did try to sign JJoe long term but obviously no deal was done. So the Bengals move on. Sure the Bengals get compensatory draft picks but the Bengals seem to be taking a page from the Carolina Panthers in letting their best vets take a walk. 14 mill for JJoe. 9 mill for Benson. Then there is the wandering QB who gets 11 mill if he stays. That is 34 mill for 3 guys. That is 33% of their payroll for 3 guys. Impossible for a small market team.

    I wonder if Andrew Luck is seeing the Bengals as a likely destination in 2012? Does he have a red shirt year available to avoid such a career ending fate?

Leave a Reply